Saturday, January 24, 2015

ARNAB GOSWAMI CUT A SORRY FIGURE BEFORE KIRAN BEDI

Arnab Goswami –the news vendor – for TOI in ‘Times Now’ Channel cut a sorry figure before Kiran Bedi.
Having acquired a dubious distinction of being the most damaging TV anchor, Arnab Goswami while interviewing Kiran Bedi on line became ashamed of his own remark regarding Bedi when he said that the files she was showing might have been ‘BJP’s file and not her own’.  To this she objected and said in a straight forward manner that either he should trust her or write off the whole matter; he cannot go further in this manner.  Kiran Bedi was in the midst of answering questions and she had already answered about ten such questions, but when uncharitable and unethical questions, almost a type of cherry picking, started out of context regarding Munde and others, Bedi in most submissive voice said that she has to attend other channels too and had little time at her disposal and yet she permitted ‘one last’ question of his (Arnab’s) choice to be asked.   And Arnab asked her ‘last question’ regarding instant change in her ideology to which she answered that it was a change from neutrality to national voice.  However, Arnab Goswami was bent upon creating a possible rift between BJP leadership and Kiran Bedi on the one hand and bringing Bedi into confrontation with Kejriwal on the other, through his journalistic astuteness.  Since Arnab could not crack the hard nut as Bedi is, and cut a sorry figure as not being able to pull her down to his satisfaction, and ‘damage’ her image, he continued to muddle with the Channel on his own by asking a few quick questions continuously, over lapping his voice on her's, and not even expecting the answers as Bedi had no time and Arnab too had realized the fact that he would ask questions in future as this was not going to be the last interview.  Bedi had said that this was the beginning of the interviews and she could devote more time in future interviews.  To this Arnab said emphatically that he had several tough questions to ask in ‘future’ and would also interview Kejriwal.  

Where the question of running away of Kiran Bedi does arise, when she answered his last question and Arnab kept many tough questions for the ‘future’?  The idea of future interview was proposed by Arnab Goswami himself.  The Channel ‘Times Now’ is a perfect liar and a false propagandist.  Bedi had not run away from interview.  The session was supposed to be ended with the last question.

For a news vendor only news is important and not the time of the person who is being interviewed.  One must watch this on line interview along with the full transcript to finalize one’s own impression.  To collaborate the factual details and for clearing misinformation, one should visit other sites too like 'the fearless Indians'  and for reading the transcript of the last question and watching the same on the video loaded by them.  Arnab Goswami is a master craftsman and a great actor in keeping his poker like face intact while creating mischievous overlapping of his voice on his object's and generating a vine video to give a false but desired impression and result.

   

Sunday, January 18, 2015

KIRAN BEDI JOINS BJP WITH A BANG


Kiran Bedi joins BJP with a bang. Kiran Bedi is the need of the time, while Kejriwal is the real future of Delhi. R N Misra Delhi needs Kiran Bedi at this hour on various grounds, but this cannot provide any futuristic aspiration or great ambition for the State. Bedi and Kejriwal belong to the same genus and both genetically are the product of the same crusade of anti-corruption started by Anna Hazare. Both were agitators, protestors and campaigners, but remained almost apolitical for quite some time like Justice Hedge who too had supported Anna at that time. While Anna Hazare kept alive the Gandhian values and tradition in him and did not approve of politicization of the movement for seeking power, Kejriwal chose otherwise, the lesser alternative, creating a party of his own. It was also the need of the hour - most imperative and challenging. At that time many MPs of several political parties (including BJP’s) had challenged Anna to come forward as elected representative of the people to the Parliament if he was so much worried about his Lokpal Bill. These political parties were all united and opposed to Jan Lokpal Bill. They never supported Anna whole heartedly or else some of the MPs must have resigned. Anna like Gandhi depended on people’s power, non-violence and courage of inner self. He fasted for the cause and his thirteen-day fast unto death rocked the nation. Kejriwal was such a direct product of that awakened India. It was greater being Anna or his associate than being an MP or a party leader. Still, however, theoretically there was a political challenge posed before Anna Hazare. Kejriwal accepted the challenge under most odd circumstances. Anna was not happy but later on blessed him for his endeavour in forming a party. It was not only needed but essential. He started from scrap. He had not even a paisa to organize the party. He formed his party in the most simplistic way almost unceremoniously. He called it a party as well as a movement. Kiran Bedi was indecisive then, but was active in her own way. She was half way between Anna Hazare and power politics. She was internally in the state of turmoil. Kejriwal kept on his ways hoping to change the society in his own style. He had two wings of his activities – agitation and power – both were intertwined. Indian political scene was changed much rapidly with the emergence of Narendra Modi at the helm of nation’s affairs. This prompted many people and parties to woo him. Kiran Bedi was one of them. One cannot dismiss Kiran Bedi simply as an opportunist. She has caliber and thronged with opportunities several times. She is perhaps the perfect person that the State of Delhi needs presently and admirably at the top. Her image is like that of a Shaktimann – a highly empowered woman; a power-crane that lifts and elevates; a roller that levels all. Yes, she dares to do what is good and undo what is bad. She seems to be a trinity of power of creation, protection and gentle destruction too, if needed. Her entry to BJP or politics should not be taken lightly. Politics of the State of Delhi intermittently played by Congress and BJP has ruined its base of effective governance. This politics of both the parties proved to be good for some people but bad and ugly for the rest of the State. There were no hard lines to work out new schemes for the State. Things were moved on ad hoc basis. All eyes were centered round votes and winning elections. Perhaps joining of Bedi serves the same purpose for BJP. Politics became the same last resort as was termed by George Bernard Shaw and as aptly this tailor made quote applies to Indian politicians. Kejriwal distinctly tried to refine it. But he was new, inexperienced and almost lone to fight the battle. He did mistakes, but still an energetic and powerful person in him, is showing passion to deliver good to the State. He is a well meaning person and it is unfortunate that Bedi has joined the party to betray her old friend and colleague. Kiran Bedi knows Delhi and Delhi knows her well. Bedi can set her priorities accurately. She knows how to work and how to make others work. Presently, Delhi-life has fallen on thorns and is bleeding. Nirbhayas are calling her to take the reins, not as a politician, but as a protector, a mother and a saviour. Delhi has become a criminal State – almost a rape capital of the country. She has to prove her mettle. Our daughters, sisters, mothers do not feel safe on Delhi roads, in parks, in public and private transport, in day and in night. We are degenerated and feel helpless. Let Kiran Bedi come in her old frame as a tough woman. Her nick name Crane Bedi has still not wiped off. Kiran Bedi comes as a hope for Delhi. She can prove to be a real Kiran – a ray of light - for Delhi and the nation. Delhi CM needs more power to exercise than politics. Coming of Bedi is always welcome. But BJP should not play politics with her as Congress played with Kejriwal. But Bedi is not a politician in real sense of the term and any party at any time can betray her. Even internal defection can play havoc. She has no roots in the party she has joined. Like Kejriwal her stay may be short lived. If she does not come in her original self and compromises with power politics, she would not be serving the people of Delhi well. And if she adopts her rough tough attitude as she did during lawyer’s strike in the past, party would not allow her to stay. This would be her dilemma and she might prove to be another Kejriwal. In Indian politics of to-day, the genes of Gandhi and Anna are missing. How can their disciples survive with the values of truthfulness and honesty? If one analyses Bedi’s career, achievement and activities one finds that she is a strict disciplinarian, full of courage and vitality. Her police and administrative training has made her so. She is strong; self cultured and has a mission and vision of life. She can even work in odds but given congenial atmosphere she can deliver good results. She has started her police career from Delhi and proved to be quite tough and upright officer. She was wedded to several controversies too like, lathi charge on lawyers protesting outside her office; wrongfully trying to get her daughter admitted to MBBS seat; coming in contact with Shobhraj and people say it was he who made her a writer and corrected the manuscript – ‘I Dare’. And in return, he was released. She has earned many laurels to live on but has to quit the job when due promotion was denied to her. She is an activist and reformer. She is now learning the game of politics, challenging the member of her own clan -  the civil activists. How long will she manage a political life which thrives on distrust, corruption and maneuverability is yet to be seen? As a hard nut to crack, Kiran Bedi can hardly be used as a pawn to counter Kejriwal. She would never agree to it nor Kejriwal directly confront her. Both belong to the same school of thought, and Sangh Pariwar is just a new home for her and is very difficult to be assimilated with her persona. She has always kept herself at arm’s length from shorts wearing and saffron colour boys. She cannot compromise her dignity in the company of ill trained people. She rarely likes to be at grassroots level and lacks a democratic temper. However, BJP can improve its chances of winning the election by putting Kiran Bedi as a CM face. Neither Harsh Vardhan nor Smrit Irani can match her in calibre and quality. In this respect the BJP’s move to bring Kiran Bedi in its fold is an added advantage. But this can work in the long run only if BJP is capable of keeping its house intact. Though victory of BJP in forth coming assembly polls is a foregone conclusion, what is important is the stability of Kiran Bedi if she is forcibly made CM. candidate. Bedi as an outsider cannot command that respect which is available automatically to an insider. Had Kiran Bedi joined politics much earlier during Parliamentary elections, the ground for Bedi would have become more solid by now. The present move of Bedi would be termed as opportunistic but any time, this type of decision would have been called opportunistic. Even Kejriwal was not spared and Anna called him opportunist. This is a political gimmick and a buzzword and the term ‘opportunism’ has almost lost its meaning. Every time is a time to join politics. There is nothing good or bad in it. It is like learning a new game, going for studies to gain knowledge and experience or making a decision for love and getting married. It is better late than never. There is nothing wrong if Bedi has joined politics, a bit late, but in a more settled and secured position.

Friday, October 24, 2014

ON KHUSHWANT SINGH - TRUTH, COURAGE AND AGNOSTICISM: AN OBITUARY

Khushwant Singh: Of Truth, Courage and Agnosticism - An Obituary Khushwant Singh, a prominent journalist and a noted novelist, breathed his last silently at noon on Thursday, March 20, 2014. He lived his life perfectly well to his satisfaction almost nearing a century (99) which was a rare achievement keeping all his vitals intact up to the end. On the eve of his departure, he had his last Patiala peg of single malt whisky with golden fried prawns on Wednesday at 7pm sharp. The next day he got up at 5 am and as usual along with daily papers, he had his mental exercise with crosswords puzzle – almost a type of hobby he had developed – and when tired got to sleep, this time for an everlasting sleep, not to wake up again. The end was supposed to have set in between 12.05-12.55 pm in his sleep. He had been for the last few years in dialogue with death. The idea had obsessed him; he talked much about it; played with the nuances of its philosophical approach; wrote a lot on it sportingly, and never was afraid of it. He took it as a peripheral aspect of life. In fact, life to him was more important which reflected in varieties of work and various form of actions. He believed in work culture and discarded worship. He never wasted his time in religious rituals, prayers, meditation and gup-shup. He was least concerned with the word God and was quite vocal about it. In this respect he surpassed Einstein who only at the far end of his life tried to express his idea about God – the word - which he did not believe. Khuswant Singh, even when he was young, had a clear cut outlook about non-existence of God. Religion to him was acceptable with its non-fundamentalist profoundness, but God for him was far away from reality. It might sound contradictory to many, but he was quite clear in his approach to life – a self proclaimed agnostic, a non-worshipper and a blasphemer. He was the man who knew his strengths and weaknesses. He had a positive approach to life making most of it through work and pursuit of fruitful activities. Though born almost like a prince in a well to do family and ‘walked with kings (and higher ups) yet (he) had a common touch’ as his son Rahul Singh has very aptly put it quoting Kipling. He had a bit of grudge against his writing career. Why did not he start as a novelist much earlier in life? He could have done so better as a writer. He was almost a contemporary of V.S.Naipaul who had achieved international status in the literary world as a writer and a novelist. Khushwant Singh took to writing much later in life and the field of journalism and contemporary politics had a toll on his literary genius. It had given him name and fame but took a lot in return by not allowing him an elevated position in the world of literature. He had the capability of achieving much higher a place to what he had really achieved. Journalism is a time consuming and risky business which thrives only in its temporariness. It helps to rise instantly but never brings depth of a literary charm, satisfaction, a prize, a Booker, a Nobel. He missed the opportunity of a whole time literary writer, a narrator, a novelist and standing in the line of a well recognized man of letters early in his life. As a journalist he was able to produce, train and nurture serious scholars and editors, Akbars and Karkarias, but missed the whole life chance of becoming a Naipaul, a Wilson, a Moore or a Fowles. He stands much behind them, although he has had better privileges and longevity of life. He has yet to be assessed as a novelist with his limited stock and range of production separately. Writing on sex has not been his weakness, but strength, strategy, and a hobby. He has opted for sex oriented subject matter and style of writing because he has firm belief that it sells like a hot cake; it is a central theme of every body’s life and has a larger scope for writing and provides larger circulation and wider audience. But he has never tried to become sublime as sex occupied higher place in his life than love. He seldom rises to a higher plane of love. For Khushwant Singh love finds its ultimate destiny in sex and lust. They are intermingled and inseparable. His populist ways have been a constraint in his achieving higher levels and greater pursuits of writing. It checked him to soar high like a star in sky. It stopped him to become a timeless writer transcending the boundaries of agelessness. Journalism restricted him to temporary realities. He could travel only from The Illustrated Weekly to The Hindustan Times that too after many efforts put up by Sanjay Gandhi and he became his “Bhakt” on that count. There seemed to be a great contrast when one looked at The Weekly days of Khushwant - the time he joined, and when he left it. There were two aspects of it. It was Khushwant Singh who brought its sale many fold (from 60,000 to 4,50,000) and it was he who brought it to the point of closing down too. It was a paradoxical situation. The Illustrated Weekly ceased to be a respectable family magazine – for every house hold, family, and drawing room. Bannet Coleman & Co was much disturbed by it. In fact, it produced a wrong signal and Khushwant Singh’s term of editorship ended without delay or any extension. Khuswant Singh converted the magazine to the caliber of a Play Boy. It soared high, but it became a carrier of too much of paper sex, gossips and cheap humour. Khushwant Singh never exhibited author’s journalism. It lacked the literary charm. It symbolized Hinglish style of ‘Roti-making and Chappal-faking’ language developed and adored by Khushwant. It was said that with Khushwant Singh the Illustrated Weekly of India had attained its perfection and peak, and with him also started its decay and downfall. Even Kamath, who succeeded him, failed to check its deceleration and imminent close down. His other distraction was his unacceptable punching humour tending to farcical situation and creating unending annoyance. It never became classical; it attained only a populist way and vanished the moment it was released. It was mere a collection of jokes, some acknowledged, other anonymously projected, and he worked them out as an editor, getting also published in book form in his name almost becoming a farcical character himself of the rank of either Banta or Santa who will perhaps survive through the eternity. This sense of humour was isolated from real life and could not attain any literary charm, a well expressed form and style, sublimity, relief or emancipation. It never hit the imagination, but spoiled the taste, the ambience, the individual and group behaviour of understanding to overcome the socio-cultural inhibition and relief of tension. He unfairly caricatured his own image, society and people whom he represented. He showed the exemplary strength of character as an editor when he supported Indira Gandhi during the Emergency days. It was not a sudden advocacy. One has to understand Khushwant Singh’s basic adherence to the principles of democracy and its real purpose. One has to understand the times, the delicate situations, the meaning behind the utterances, and the hidden agenda made to spoil the governance of the period. Khushwant supported Indira and the imposition of the Emergency as a logical conclusion of JP’s anarchistic style of politicking. While Khushwant Singh succeeded in his stand, the most of journalist fraternity failed to understand it because they worked only on the lines of cartel behavior guided by the capitalist bosses. Indian journalism has never been free, the way freedom of press is really understood. It has always remained a caged bird. It works under the lense and surveillance of industrial groups of the type of Goenkas, Sahu Jains, Birlas, Andrews, Karnanis, Kasturis etc. Indian press remains censured always mentally and emotionally by their crony money magnates. So when censorship was imposed during Emergency it was the group like Goenkas or JP’s which was hit most because this pseudo revolutionary movement was highly projected through the press. The press was already a jailed bird controlled by industrial giants and others. What mattered if they were not allowed to magnify an anarchist movement? Khuswant Singh survived Emergency because Bannet Coleman as a unit was never influenced individually as was Goenkas by JP. Infect JP lived on Goenkas patronage. Had any Daily news paper stopped its circulation or production in protest against press censureship? Had any editor left his job in protest against his freedom? JP was neither a socialist nor a democrat. He paid lip sympathy to Gandhism and always misguided the people who surrounded him; who considered him as a revolutionary or an avatar to bring total revolution which flopped within two and a half years and Indira like Phoenix re-emerged from ashes to punch JP’s sense of inflated ego. ‘JP failed yet again’ wrote one of his sycophants and when Indira met JP at Kadam Kuan (Patna), he had no words but to appreciate her courageous victory. JP said to Indira,” you had a bright past and I wish you a brighter future”. Those who lived during the Emergency times and still dishonouring the era of discipline – Anushasanparva – or discarding Emergency must answer the nature and causes of Indira’s re-emergence as a victorious leader. Many adulatory books or “JP Chalisas” had been written by journalists, civil servants and academics but none had courage to answer: why Indira re-emerged and why total revolution turned to be a total flop? The followers of JP still keep this dead movement close to their chest in the hope that it might come to life someday like Macaque monkey keeping the dead infant close to the heart. Khushwant Singh was one of the great personalities of India who had seen merit in Emergency. This was the truth of his life and somewhere in his consciousness Khushwant found a Gandhian touch in him as far as the courage of conviction was concerned. Khushwant had always admired Gandhi. As a student of Modern School, he had an occasion to meet Gandhi who created a lasting influence on him. The strength of truth provided Khushwant Singh a special mindset to generate a sense of righteousness of his own understanding. This elevated him amongst the journalists of his times – he was The Master. As an editor of Illustrated Weekly he had a cover story to publish about the pitfalls of JP’s movement. And he did so courageously while JP was alive. What Khushwant Singh predicted had happened. Emergency was imposed and JP was jailed. In the luxurious ambience of PGI, Chandigarh, well protected and carefully looked after by doctors, nurses, servants and bureaucrats who willingly worked for JP as his assistants, advisors and secret messengers. JP had an occasion to spew up venom in the elaborate elegy written as a Prison-Diary. The conditions of Emergency were of JP’s own creation. There was no alternative to the anarchy brought about by him. JP had given a final call for armed forces to revolt. No government, worth the name, would have tolerated such a situation. JP was in hurry to become a Marx, a Lenin and a Mao – combined in one. But history had pulled him down as a failed leader or a fascist who could not successfully ‘March on Delh’ before the Emergency. Those who still adore JP must answer: where is the total revolution? One has to admit Khushwant Singh as a truthful and courageous editor who admired Emergency to its core even in the midst of all opposition from his journalist fraternity. And he ultimately had to pay the price for it. Unperturbed by trials or tribulations, he stood on his ground firm like a rock of strength with full conviction and faith that Emergency was inevitable. Khushwant Singh’s truthfulness had been reflected much when he wrote quintessential books on his life like – Absolute Khushwant: The Low-Down on Life, Death and Most Things In Between; Khushwantnama: The Lessons of My Life; The Good, The Bad and Ridiculous; Agnostic Khushwant: There Is No God; Truth, Love and A Little Malice; Women and Men In My Life etc. As a writer he believes that truth must be told, accepted and worked out. Nothing except truth should prevail. It is truth that is exhibited in all his writings – journalistic or literary. He is comfortable with it; sometimes hilarious and other times bitter too. He left nothing untold about his life: of love, dejection, hope and despair; of sex, women and prostitution; of friends, family, home and hearth; of death, deception and defeat – in a sense all about his professional and personal life. It is this revelation which makes him different from Gandhi‘s openness who had concealed his clear way of approaching his love for a woman of Tagore’s family (as discovered by his grandson later) and his practical indulgence in prostitution in London. Revelation does not mean fooling the readers; it is courageous way of embracing bitter truth as Khushwant Singh has done. His truthfulness and agnosticism are the outcome of his transparent behavior, openness of mind and clear vision of life. He is bold enough to acknowledge his failures and also a bit of his ugliness, malice, sex, bitterness and blasphemy. Khushwant Singh had a peculiar sense of imagining his death and writing about his obituary or own epitaph. At one time he was so enamored with the idea that he wanted to have a grave of his own. Well and good. He was trying to create a non-sense style of humour to make others rejoice on his death. Sometimes he felt ‘The Tribune’ would write this or ‘The Times of India’ write that. But it did not happen. Of all his prophecies, perhaps one stood correct out of his ‘make belief’ obituaries. It reads,”Khushwant Singh, a noted novelist, died in his sleep……”. He wrote his own Epitaph emphasizing how he should be remembered – ‘as a critic, a sod, a blasphemer and a nasty writer (not a good man to remember?), thank God he is dead’. But the most fitting Epitaph is as follows (in Khushwant Singh’s own words with a bit alteration and much addition) and with an apology to this great liberated soul: “Here lies the man whose pen had no condom to wear”; He was a literary sort of Vikky Donor and a great seer. He produced and nurtured writers, journalists, as the Peer; And left behind his affairs, to mourn, crates of whisky and beer.

On Reading 'Half Girlfriend' - A Critique

On Reading ‘Half Girlfriend’: A Critique. The writer of ‘Half Girlfriend’ has caricatured almost the whole of Bihar by introducing a character – Madhav – originally hailed from the hinterland of Patna, but might be said as a representative of any district of Bihar – call him a typical ‘Bihari’ - who happened to be from anywhere of the interior of Musahari or Motihari; Chhapra or Madhopura. The story moves around two main characters, another Delhiite girl, who under certain circumstances becomes his friend – both school fellows - and are proud of being Stephanians. The writer has specifically tried to define the concept of half girlfriend. But it is a confused word and may be interpreted in different ways. The term half brother or half sister is quite prevalent, but concepts like half married and half widowed are of recent origin. In the same way, half girlfriend in its origin, is a recent term, and is liable to be vaguely interpreted by the author himself. In any case, half girlfriend is not very attractive title of the book. Dear author, girlfriend is a value loaded word. It means many things to many persons. It is hope for life. Possession of it is the creation of life, dispossessing means death. Don’t vivisect it by making half or a quarter of it. Love is not surgically operated as you have done. Like his other stories, the writer had again tried to be autobiographical and could not detach himself from the story. A good writer dominates his writings through his thoughts, words and style, and not as a person or a character. Have you ever heard Shakespeare appearing in any of his plays? It is another point that you are trying to set a new trend in writing. Well and good. Your marketing management training has lured you to do so. It is possible this fine story may land you some day in the sphere of acting as a Bollywood star. But this self characterization has its own limits. When the imagination fails a writer, what is left is autobiographical form of writing. You might not be aware of it, but you must be losing some inner talent as a writer in a slow process. A writer must move out of his own orbit. How can a writer expand his horizon unless he changes the orbit? The story of half girlfriend is primarily written for teenagers who accept any form or style of writing without any comment, if it suits their sense of sex and love. They are governed by these basic instincts without any thoughtful provocation. But the writer of half girlfriend does not want to go beyond it. A boy meets girl; they are separated for good. But they meet again only to get separated. They ultimately come together. The concept of half girlfriend is smashed somewhere in the very process of narration only to be converted into a type of live-in relationship – half married, half divorced and a child in between. The writer seems to be a protagonist of new social order – changing the mindset - of young generation. Very subtly he had introduced father- daughter bitter chocolate relationship and also tried to open the path of divorce and re-marriage. In the age of shrinking world and having acquired advanced technical skill, one can hope to serve two Hemispheres together – East and West. It is a sea change from rural Bihar to New York, shuttling almost at will. The writer seems to be weak in style of his narration and describing the story. He seldom tries to read the situation minutely. His expression lacks the literary charm. He does not touch the line of a novelist. He goes on adding one book after another but simply remains a story teller. He is good in making a plot – a fine story – but he is always in hurry to create events, and developing the story, and by doing so he leaves behind much valuable aspect of literary element that goes through the process of a masterly expression of thought and style. He is in no way being called a novelist in literary parlance. The writer claims to be a catalyst of change. But in what way he thinks so? What has he given to the society through his language? He is getting more and more debased in the use of words. His diction is simply getting horrible. ‘Deti hai to de varna kat le’. What does this mean? Mr. Writer, please keep in mind that whatever be the stature of a woman in society - she must be dealt with dignity. Even prostitutes have their self respect. Are you going to elevate womankind with such a language? As a writer you cannot absolve the responsibility. These are not Madhav’s words. This is the writer’s Hindi – not Bihari (Bhojpuri) language – but pure and simple Punjabi-Hindi mixed dialect. This very sentence makes the book a trash. And the word F**king has been so profusely used in the book that it has become the catchword – rather a password – of the book, half girlfriend, without using that you cannot enter into the text to read the sublime passages. ‘F**k or get f**ked’ is the message teenagers can receive from your book. And here in this book you have used abusive word Ch***a also. How nice of you Mr. Writer, to think of changing the society in this way! If you want to become a good novelist you have to mend your language. You have to develop a literary style of creativity with a deep sense of expression which is pleasing to mind and soul. You never try to describe landscape; never try to form images through words; never write passages to beautify text. Bare story surrounded by events with common narration does not make a novel. A novel is a form of writing which requires the creativity of an artist, profoundness of a linguist and perfection of a writer who is able to describe the quality of observation through the choice of his words, easily to be moulded at his command. He must have the sensitivity of revelation and ability to impress upon his readers the view points with his capacity to organize a story of an architectural quality, brick by brick, stone by stone. A good plot – a nice story – is of utmost importance. It must have a definite beginning, middle and an end. It must flow with ups and downs creating rhythm through words. It must carry the universality of some of the deepest human emotions to sustain the story. It is music within heart which comes out spontaneously and reaches the zenith to serve a climax and slowly arrives at the destination as a river flows down calmly into the sea. There is nothing like a set pattern, but the designer has to invent paradigm to bring out a sense of in depth satisfaction and achievement in each of his successive creation. Somehow ‘half girlfriend’ does not come to these expectations. In spite of a good story and a plot, it lacks the smoothness of narration, depth of emotions and sublimity of diction or language. No doubt, the writer has capacity to create a good stuff for his book, but as a columnist or a journalist, he always remains within bounds of a dead line for his story to be sent to the press. This has created in him a hurried style of writing and he has adjusted to the temporariness of journalistic writing than to a more sustained and value added concept of a man of letters. He fills columns but does not prettify his writings. He has been for the last ten years in this profession, but still lacks maturity. If observed minutely, he seemed to have deteriorated a lot in the use of words – rather became more abusive - and dwelled on the surface of the story. How one can make Bihar proud? By f**king a girl and win her over? Has the writer not degenerated in his understanding of the state? There are instances which count in making a story worthy for appreciation or rejection and here one may find many such points of rejection. It is not novel-material but pulp fiction stuff. How can such a writer think that he should be ‘missed’, if not remembered? At most he can be put to the level of yester year (Hindi) writers like Kushwaha Kant or Gulshan Nanda – an English version of them. They had written good stories which were also converted into films, but survived for a decade or two only and never were ‘missed’ because others were in the pipeline to fill the gap. The writer of half girlfriend has great power of creating stories, generating plots, but he does not want to come out of quick fame of journalistic style. He is satisfied with that. He is in essence a columnist, not a writer of great promise. He has to develop the other facet of his personality as a writer. He must come out as a man who knows the art of narration, observation and description; the man who has the capacity to develop literary style of expression, the man who has potential of a novelist of some name and fame. But he has to change his style. I do not want to see him transformed into a Hardy or a Naipaul. Centuries have lapsed; times have changed a lot. But permanent truth can never be obsolete. In ‘half girlfriend’ one may find some traces of a good novelist in making. Just mark the letter – wonderfully set and drafted - in section33, page 189 by Riya to Madhav. This letter surpasses even Hardy’s letter when Tess writes to her lover (in a different context of course) addressing, ‘My Own Husband….’. This letter of Riya creates the climax of the story. It is worth reading, preserving, and appreciating. There are other better expressions too, but they run only up to a line or two. This is unsolicited advice to the writer of ‘half girlfriend’ to accept the challenge as a novelist and rise above the level of a story teller. In spite of all its failings, ‘half girlfriend’, is worthy for reading and appreciating.

Monday, October 6, 2014

Deepika Padukone scolds the Editor : TOI and it's lack of respect for women

The editor of the online entertainment section of TOI tried to redo a Khushwant by morphing – rather zooming and highlighting through an arrow and a circle - the worst kind of act, for better attention of the readers to prove his degenerated sense of sexism with a caption ‘OMG …Cleavage Show’ of an otherwise simple professional photograph of a popular Bollywood actress. What was there in that image which prompted the editor to highlight it? Has he not seen the cleavage of any other woman in his life? With this perverted sense of editorship you can go on making your online edition a sexshop by putting as many arrows, indications and images of woman’s body – breasts, buttocks and pelvis etc till it is contested in the court of law as porno or the sure way of outraging the modesty of a woman. But the common public is not attracted towards it. It pulls down your prestige and makes the mockery of your paper. Perhaps you know the under lying cause how and why Khushwnat singh was fired from Illustrated Weekly? The magazine had ceased to be the carrier of respectable reading material for every household, family and drawing room. Its readers were getting confined to the clubs and coffee houses. Bennett, Coleman and Co had sensed its degeneration and promptly closed down the Weekly. Do you want the same fate for your online edition? People will not remain silent if you do this bakvas any further. Every woman has a right to have dignified and respectful place in the society. You must assure she gets it and see that her modesty is not hurt in any form by your actions directly or indirectly. The time is not far away when apart from Verma Commission’s new definition of rape, the court will also draw a line beyond that print or electronic media cannot go to attract attention through semi or complete nude photographs of women. You put black strip to cover your malafide intentions. But now this will not do. The photo-journalism is a branch of activity which has devoured the good sense of writing and understanding of the editor. Please be in your limit and don’t show to the world that you do not respect your women. You admitted that the heading could be better. But at the same time, in retaliation, you loaded more photographs to bring the situation at the same point from where it had originated. Have you really lost your sense? What you want to project? Yes, she is a woman. She has breasts. So what? She is young, attractive and beautiful. But she is not meant for your entertainment edition to attract readers. You have no right to put arrow or circle over her photograph. It is morphing of a new order. It is a crime. The fault lies in your thought process, approach and understanding of women. It is against sexism, erotica and sensuousness that the women are fighting. The aftermath of Nirbhaya episode should have taught you a lesson. But you have forgotten the tension the society is passing through. You are living in a society which has certain laws – social and legal. You have to obey them. Don’t retaliate if a woman asks you to behave in an orderly manner. She gets now more protected under the law of state than she used to have earlier. Putting online images and zoom them in your interest amount to outraging her modesty. Whatever is the level, the status or position of a woman – high or low – she has to be dealt with dignity, honour and respect? A beggar woman, a household maid or an office girl, an actress or a selected beauty queen, all have the same dignity as a woman as our daughters and sisters. There should be no distinction among them as far as the dignity of a woman is concerned. Why you try to pull her down? Why you call her a calendar girl? How would you feel if I call you a news paper vendor or a hawker? There is no difference between an editor and a news hawker. Both bring news to our door step. You must remember that women are not a sex signs. They are trying hard to change this image. And you must try to understand difference between professional and personal life. It may also be said as the reel vs. real life. You want to project that the photographs which you uploaded in retaliation as a reply belong to her real life. No. They are all stills from professional life. Women are fighting for equality and empowerment but by bringing in a woman’s or man’s anatomy to attract attention is a cheap form of journalism – print or electronic. Don’t peep into a woman’s body; don’t zoom to expose her skin pixel by pixel. Please have respect for women off-screen. You have highlighted the image of the actress encircling her breasts and cleavage. Why? Are you full of shit or have any sense of art form? Your arrows and circles create a doubtful journalism. Surely, the world of online is different from news paper. But underlying philosophy is the same. You have to have a healthy outlook of journalism. You have miserably failed in this test. You seem to have wrongly landed in this field. You can best fit as a pimp. You can attract more clients in that business than what you do to attract readers for your online entertainment section. There is an instance in our cultural history. ‘In the reign of King Dilip, there were no poor, no thieves, no fear among men and women. There was equality among people and no clash of material interest and when there were no unchaste men how could unchaste women be?’ It only means that man is elevating as well as degenerating factor for a woman. Let us accept this truth and the reality of our social life. Let us lift our women high in our mental setup and don’t degrade them only as sex symbols. She needs our help. She is God’s best creation. We must give her dignity, respect and love. I request Bennett, Coleman and co to look into the matter seriously and sack the editor(s) of the online edition of TOI as well as the editor of the entertainment section, if there is any, and replacing them by women editors so that it may get rid of pelvis-penis kind of journalism which has put your online edition into great controversy. Women journalists will at least not play the arrow-circle game and this will also be the test for the management how much respect they show for women.

Wednesday, February 19, 2014

Labyrinth of Rail Tariff Authrity


LABYRINTH OF RAIL TARIFF AUTHORITY The proposed rail tariff authority is a complex institutional phenomenon; the more it is worked out, the greater is the complication, intricacy and confusion involved in it. One is sure to be lost in its incompatibility and impracticality of thought process and action. The idea was first mooted to establish Indian Railways Regulatory Authority (IRRA) by The Rakesh Mohan Committee Report (2001) along with other innovative recommendations. But it was not taken up seriously because the committee stood for corporatization of the railways and almost proposed to dismantle the Ministry and the Railway Board. Not knowing about the consequences, the idea was reopened by Dinesh Trivedi (2012), although the railways’ professionals and think tank did not consider it a welcome step. Later on, other ministers - Pawan Kumar Bansal and Mallikarjun Kharge - under the pressure of the Planning Commission - took up the cause for establishing Rail Tariff Authority. Though Bansal had to leave the railways, it was Kharge who ultimately succeeded in getting the proposal of Tariff Authority passed by the Cabinet. It is at present lying with the Ministry of Law. The tragedy with Indian Railways is that it is molested, time and again, by its own mentor for personal and party pleasure. Who is to check the top brass? And how is it possible to bell the cat? When it comes to Railways Budget Session, the minister feels elevated – a time for bounty distribution – mostly unplanned expenditure is added year after year. And the back log grows so heavily that no amount of Vision 2020 or any other such Vision would suffice to end this process. The past experience shows that the malady lies somewhere within the ministry of railways. It is the minister who needs to be checked, controlled and stopped from making imprudent and whimsical decisions. But what is the way out? Is there any authority over him? Is there any regulatory body to mend his ways? Constitutionally none, except the Parliament to which the minister is answerable. For the past several years, the railways has shown unprecedented ways of bringing the department to near bankruptcy. It seems to be the fall out of insensible decisions taken by the ministers like popular schemes of no hike in tariffs, unplanned expenditure, unfeasible projects and adding up limitlessly new trains and new programmes every year without any financial provisions for the same. It is perhaps for this reason that a consensus was created to establish Rail Tariff Authority. It sounds good to have such an authority provided it is feasible. Perhaps neither the Planning Commission nor the Cabinet has given a second thought to it about its impracticability. The idea of Rail Tariff Authority (RTA) is unrealistic, inappropriate and disruptive because of the duplicity of the authority and other related factors involved in it. It seems like creating an authority over the final authority. What type of power structure does it envisage? The most experienced financial cadre of Indian Railways and academics engaged in research studies at various rail study centres like Rail Transport Institute, Delhi, and Railways’ Staff College, Varodara, have opined that the set of players involved in railways are different than those in other tariff authorities like the Tele-Communication Sector (from where this idea is borrowed). The players of the Tele-Communication Sector are outsiders and cannot be equated with the railways. A. V. Polouse, an authority on railway finance, and former member Railway Board, has never welcomed the idea of Rail Tariff Authority. He is of the opinion that tariff authority like the Tele-Communication is working only because this sector is multi-operator-service-sector, unlike railways which is single-operator-service-sector. The railways is a single player business unit. Whom will the RTA regulate? An authority to regulate an authority! Should one regulate the Minister for Railways or for that matter the Prime Minister if he keeps the railways portfolio with him? The Rail Tariff Authority is a mismatch proposition and does not conform to the railways setup and its operative pattern. The railways as a department, and the government at the centre – both seem to be rather confused over the setting up of the Rail Tariff Authority. Perhaps it is on the basis of such a scenario that the proposed RTA has yet not taken a concrete shape and though it has got a nod from the Cabinet, the proposal is still languishing in cold storage or perhaps lying somnolent with the law ministry. The doubts regarding feasibility of the Tarff Authority have come home to the roost. The protagonists now say that if RTA has to be adopted, it must go through both ways i.e., executive and legislative. Though it is easy to establish RTA through executive order but it would remain in that case a subordinate and weak institution. Its recommendations would never be mandatory. The railways by nature and authority cannot digest any super body dominating it. It is not practically possible to do so without recourse to legislative process. It, therefore, needs an amendment in the Railways Act 1989. It is here that the conflicting opinions prevail. The nature, role and practicability of RTA have to be ascertained first. The purpose of tariff authority has to be well defined. Its functioning has to be made clear. The feasibility aspect must be judged properly. The railway ministry wants it to be an advisory body where as the government at centre thinks it to be much stronger an institution whose recommendations would be mandatory. The Cabinet Committee though in principle has accepted the establishment of a regulatory body but it has different versions of the proposed authority. The minister for railways, Mallikarjun Kharge, has said that the Cabinet has approved the proposal of establishing RTA but there are some points which are still to be clarified. What are those points are not clear. In fact, a stronger RTA needs amendment in the Railway Act. The Act should provide fine teeth to RTA to enable it to regulate railways tariffs with power, grace and dignity. In this case it would have authority to fix fares and freights binding on the railways. And, perhaps the railway administration would not accept this process on technical grounds and in the long run the Rail Tariff Authority would become useless. The railways on the other hand, has an authority to submit budget to the Parliament - an authority - which is superior to any other department functioning within the government except the Ex-Chequer, the Ministry of Finance. How can a third party intervene the functioning of the railways and the Parliament? Does the RTA want to make this power of the railways redundant? There seems to be a tussle of power being exercised between RTA’s advisory and mandatory role. This situation, in any case, should be avoided in the general interest of the railways and the people. What is use of submitting separate budget by the railways if it cannot fix fares and freights on its own? The aspect of fare and freight policy governs the gamut of railways system and functioning. If this process is changed, the railways cannot survive as a dignified department. The setting up of an intermediary body would disturb the whole power structure of the railways. A common acceptable solution has to be found so that the RTA would fix the brackets of increase or decrease of rail fares and freights taking into account input costs like fixed and variable costs, marginal and average costs and other expenditures and market conditions of demand and supply including elasticity and sensitivity aspect of passengers and consignors. However, the final authority must remain with the railways. This requires executive and legislative changes and amendments. Only the time will tell what shape the RTA takes if the government is keen to establish it. If Indian railways has to be saved from the political clutches and unrestricted power being exercised by the ministers to promote their private and party interests, the RTA with fine teeth should emerge as a solution to the present deteriorating situation or else the railways would be driven into doldrums. The railways has already experienced a damaging effect due to ministers uncontrolled behavior during the recent past and the ministry of Railways needs a shock therapy to bring it on the right track.